Cancer Quackery in Court
Serious prosecutions of fake cancer cures in Canada and the United States, from 1989 to today — who was charged, with what, and how each case actually ended.
If you or someone you know was sold a fake cure
How to report cancer fraud, and how to try to get your money back →
Who to complain to in Canada and the U.S., what to keep, small-claims and civil options, and where to find free or low-cost legal help.
What the record shows
Canada has almost no record.We found seven Canadian cases in more than three decades. Gaston Naessens was acquitted in 1989. The Criminal Code fraud charges laid against the Zoetron promoters in 2005 have no reported outcome. The two convictions we found for selling a cancer “cure” were guilty pleas under the Food and Drugs Act, both for the same bleach product.
The U.S. sends people to prison.Sentences in the U.S. cases run from probation to more than twelve years. The longest went to the sellers of “Miracle Mineral Solution” and to a California doctor whose “C-Extract” cure turned out to contain a sunscreen preservative.
Often convicted for something else.Many convictions came through a side door: contempt of an earlier court order, insurance billing, tax, adulterated devices, smuggling. The treatment itself was rarely the charge.
Big judgments, little money.Civil judgments of millions of dollars were routinely suspended because the sellers said they could not pay. The largest jury award, $105 million against Robert O. Young, has no reported collection.
What is included. Criminal charges, civil enforcement (FTC, Competition Bureau, attorneys general, FDA injunctions), regulatory-court prosecutions, and a few major civil verdicts — where the case concerned selling or providing an unproven cancer treatment. Professional discipline alone is generally left out; it is covered in Bad-MD and Bad-ND. A conviction or settlement is described only as far as the sources go; where an outcome could not be found, the table says so rather than guess. A settlement without admission is not a finding of wrongdoing.
The cases
Country:
Type:
| Country | Case | What was sold | Proceeding | Outcome | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1989 | Canada | Gaston NaessensRock Forest (Sherbrooke), Que. | 714-X, a camphor-based injection sold as a cancer treatment | Criminal Quebec criminal prosecution, tried at Sherbrooke in 1989. Sources differ on the charges: criminal negligence and fraud (Le Nouvelliste); practising medicine without a licence (Quackwatch). | Acquitted Acquitted.Le Nouvelliste, 2018; Quackwatch |
| 1991 | US | Jimmy Keller (“Tumorex”)Matamoros, Mexico; tried in Texas | Injections for cancer; diagnosis by pendulum | Criminal Federal wire fraud and conspiracy (S.D. Tex.), after he was brought from Mexico in disputed circumstances. | Convicted Convicted 1991; affirmed on appeal 1994. Quackwatch reports two years in prison, and a return to prison in 1998 for treating cancer patients.5th Cir. opinion; Quackwatch |
| 1997 | US | Dr. Stanislaw BurzynskiHouston, Tex. | Antineoplastons, an unapproved cancer drug | Criminal Federal indictment, 75 counts (fraud, interstate shipment of an unapproved drug, contempt). | Acquitted No conviction. Judge acquitted him on the fraud counts and declared a mistrial on the rest (March 1997); remaining counts dropped; jury acquitted on contempt (May 1997).Life Extension (sympathetic), 1997 |
| 1998 | US | Dr. Stanislaw BurzynskiHouston, Tex. | Antineoplastons | Civil Texas attorney general suit, Travis County. | Settled Final judgment, February 1998: antineoplastons only within FDA-approved trials, no cancer advertising, $50,000 in fees and costs.Quackwatch |
| 1998 | US | Shelvie RettmannPrior Lake, Minn. | “Rife” and radionics devices with cure claims | Civil Minnesota attorney general suit, Scott County. | Judgment Judgment, September 1998: barred from providing health services, refunds on request, $50,000 civil penalty.Rife Research Europe (reproduces the judgment) |
| 1998 | US | Dr. Nicholas GonzalezNew York, N.Y. | Coffee enemas and enzymes for cancer | Civil Malpractice suit by a uterine-cancer patient (Charell v. Gonzalez). | Judgment Multimillion-dollar verdict (1997), largely upheld on appeal in 1998; punitive damages struck.Appellate decision |
| 2000 | US | Hulda ClarkIndiana; arrested in San Diego | “Cure for all cancers”; the Zapper | Criminal Indiana charge of practising medicine without a licence (1993 sting); arrested as a fugitive in 1999. | Dismissed Dismissed April 2000 because she had not been brought to trial in time — not on the merits.Herald-Times, via HealthWatcher |
| 2000 | US | Lane Labs, Andrew and I. William LaneAllendale, N.J. | BeneFin shark cartilage and SkinAnswer cream | Civil FTC orders (2000); FDA/Justice Department injunction (2004). | Judgment $1 million to the FTC and an NCI trial (2000). 2004: products ruled unapproved drugs, permanent injunction, refunds to all buyers. Contempt of the 2000 FTC order found in 2011.FTC, 2000; Quackwatch (FDA case) |
| 2001 | US | Five “Operation Cure.All” cancer sellersPa., Ark., Fla., Tex., Wash. | Herbal salves, colloidal silver, shark cartilage, Rife-type devices | Civil FTC consent orders, and one federal preliminary injunction (June 2001). | Settled Bans on unsupported claims; refunds offered in most cases.FTC, June 2001 |
| 2002 | US | David L. Walker (DLW Consulting, “CWAT”)Olympia, Wash. | “Indian Mud” herbs, coffee enemas and an oscillator, $2,400–5,200 a course | Civil Washington attorney general and FTC. | Judgment Website shut permanently; about $230,000 refunded to 127 buyers; FTC ban on the claims (2002).Washington AG |
| 2002 | US | BioPulse InternationalSouthern California and Tijuana | Insulin-induced coma “therapy” for cancer, up to $39,900 | Civil FTC consent decrees. | Settled Claim bans; $4.3 million judgment suspended (July 2002).FTC, July 2002 |
| 2004 | US | Jason Vale (laetrile, apricot seeds)Queens, N.Y. | Laetrile and apricot seeds sold as a cancer cure | Criminal Federal criminal contempt, after breaching a 2000 FDA court injunction. | Convicted Convicted 2003; 63 months in prison (June 2004). A second federal case (2019) — outcome not found.Quackwatch; NBC News, 2019 |
| 2004 | US | Greg Caton (Lumen Foods, “Cansema”)Lake Charles, La. | Black salve and herbal “cancer” products | Criminal Federal mail fraud and unapproved new drugs (W.D. La.). | Convicted Pleaded guilty 2004; 33 months. Fled to Ecuador, returned to the US in 2009; supervised release revoked, 24 more months (2010).5th Cir. 2006; 5th Cir. 2011 (Leagle) |
| 2004 | US | CSCT Inc. (“Zoetron”), Reynolds and ArmstrongNaramata, B.C.; treatment in Tijuana | Magnetic “cell specific cancer therapy” | Civil FTC suit (2003), with help from Canada’s Competition Bureau: a temporary restraining order froze the company’s assets and shut its websites; Mexico closed the Tijuana clinic. | Settled Settled February 2004: barred from selling Zoetron; $7.65 million judgment suspended for inability to pay. No admission.FTC, Feb 2004 |
| 2004 | US | Dr. Clark Research Association, Dr. Clark Zentrum and David P. Amrein (Hulda Clark’s products)San Diego, Calif. and Switzerland | The Zapper, Syncrometer and a “21-Day Program for Advanced Cancers” | Civil FTC suit, settled November 2004. Amrein was named individually and as an officer of both companies; Hulda Clark herself was not a defendant. | Settled Barred from unsubstantiated health claims, including that the Zapper cures cancer; refunds offered to U.S. buyers. No admission. Today (checked October 2026) the Dr. Clark Research Association, now in Somers, Montana, still sells Zappers online, with an “About Us” letter signed by Amrein, and its home page repeats Clark’s claim that every cancer involves a liver parasite.FTC, 2004; Stipulated order; us.drclark.com (Oct 2026) |
| 2004 | US | Robert Barefoot and Kevin Trudeau (coral calcium)National infomercials | Coral calcium claimed to cure cancer | Civil FTC suit (2003). | Settled Barefoot (January 2004): claim ban; $3 million owed only if his financial statements prove false. Trudeau (September 2004): $2 million and an infomercial ban.SupplySide (Barefoot); FTC (Trudeau) |
| 2005 | Canada | Michael Reynolds and John Armstrong (CSCT Inc., “Zoetron”)Kitchener, Ont. and Penticton, B.C. | Magnetic “cell specific cancer therapy”; about 850 patients paid up to US$20,000 each, about US$12 million in all, including 37 known Canadian victims | Criminal Competition Bureau: 10 counts each of false or misleading representations (Competition Act) and one count of fraud over $5,000 (Criminal Code), laid August 2005. | Unknown Outcome never reported. No record of a plea, trial, stay or withdrawal has been found.Competition Bureau, 2 Aug 2005; Waterloo Region Record, 6 Aug 2005 (cited on our Zoetron page) |
| 2007 | Canada | Canadian Cancer Research Group (Bill O’Neill)Ottawa, Ont. | Amino-acid “immunotherapy” and unverifiable survival figures | Investigation CPSO investigators and Ottawa Police executed a warrant at the clinic, 10 May 2007. | No charges No charges laid. The clinic’s former medical director was disciplined by the CPSO in 2010.QuackeryWatch |
| 2007 | Canada | Dr. Ravi DevganToronto and Wallaceburg, Ont. | Carnivora for cancer patients (licence revoked 2003); later, while unlicensed, bogus injections for a family’s disabled twin sons | Criminal Criminal fraud over his treatment of the twins — not over his cancer practice. | Convicted Convicted; three years in prison. His cancer treatment cost him only his licence. Died in custody.QuackeryWatch (Bad-MD); QuackeryWatch |
| 2008 | US | Donald and Sharon BrandtMount Vernon, Wash. | Frequency devices, including a “Vibe Machine”, used on patients — among them a 32-year-old with testicular cancer who refused surgery and died | Criminal Federal adulterated-device charges (W.D. Wash.). | Convicted Pleaded guilty 2008: 30 days and home detention (him), home detention (her), $10,000 in fines.U.S. Attorney, W.D. Wash.; Seattle Times, 2007 |
| 2008 | US | Feline ButcherLos Angeles, Calif. | Nutrition counselling and remedies for cancer patient Clive McLean | Criminal Los Angeles City Attorney: 17–18 counts of practising medicine without a licence and one of grand theft. | Acquitted (unconfirmed) Reported acquitted on all counts, 14 November 2008. Not yet confirmed from a court record or news report.Religion News Blog (charges) |
| 2008 | US | “Operation False Cures” — 11 cancer-cure sellersNationwide | Laetrile, black salve, Essiac, herbal teas and other remedies | Civil FTC sweep, September 2008: six cases settled at once, five litigated. | Settled Mostly consent orders with largely suspended money judgments. At least two were dismissed: one seller could not be served, and in another the judge found the FTC had not proved the company ran the ads.FTC, Sept 2008; FTC (Gemtronics dismissal); FTC order (Omega Supply) |
| 2009 | Canada | Bioenergy Wellness Inc. (EnergyWorks Wellness Centre) and Alan GordonEdmonton, Alta. | Papimi and Magnapulse devices and a far-infrared sauna promoted for cancer | Civil Competition Bureau consent agreement registered with the Competition Tribunal — the only formal case from Project False Hope. | Settled Settled, February 2009: no cancer claims for 10 years, corrective notices, refunds on request. No fine; no admission.Consent agreement |
| 2009 | US | Roex Inc.Irvine, Calif. | Infrared sauna and supplements sold as cancer treatments | Civil FTC settlement. | Settled $3 million for refunds (2009); about 5,700 checks mailed in 2010.FTC; FTC (refunds) |
| 2010 | US | Geronimo Rubio and William Fry (American Metabolic Institute)Bonita, Calif. and Tijuana | Cancer “vaccines” and other treatments at a Tijuana clinic | Criminal Federal health-care fraud (false insurance bills) and tax charges (S.D. Cal.). | Convicted Pleaded guilty; Fry 14 months, Rubio 12 months (2010). Convicted for the billing, not the treatment.QuackeryWatch |
| 2011 | US | Kurt Donsbach (Hospital Santa Monica)Bonita, Calif. and Rosarito, Mexico | Unapproved drugs for cancer patients | Criminal San Diego County felony charges, 2009, including practising medicine without a licence and selling misbranded drugs to cancer patients. (Earlier: a 1996 federal conviction for smuggling and tax evasion.) | Convicted Pleaded guilty to 13 felonies; one year in county jail and 10 years’ probation (April 2011).San Diego Reader, 2011 |
| 2013 | US | Dr. Christine Daniel (Sonrise Wellness Center)Mission Hills, Calif. | “C-Extract” herbal cancer cure — found to contain a sunscreen preservative and beef flavouring | Criminal Federal mail and wire fraud, tax evasion, witness tampering (C.D. Cal.). | Convicted Convicted 2011; 14 years in prison and $1.28 million forfeiture (May 2013).U.S. Attorney, C.D. Cal. |
| 2015 | US | Louis Daniel Smith (Project GreenLife)Spokane, Wash. | “Miracle Mineral Solution” marketed for cancer and other diseases | Criminal Federal conspiracy, misbranding and smuggling (E.D. Wash.). | Convicted Convicted by a jury; 51 months (October 2015).Justice Department |
| 2015 | US | Toby McAdam (Risingsun Health)Livingston, Mont. | Black salve and other “cancer” products | Criminal Criminal contempt after breaching a 2010 FDA consent decree. | Convicted Pleaded guilty (December 2015): four months in prison and $80,000 in liquidated damages.Justice Department, Dec 2015 |
| 2015 | US | Daniel Chapter One and James FeijoPortsmouth, R.I. | BioShark, 7 Herb Formula and other cancer products | Civil FTC order (2009), upheld on appeal (2010); civil contempt (2012). | Judgment $3.5 million civil penalty plus $1.3 million in consumer relief and a lifetime ban on selling supplements (2015); upheld 2016. Refunds were later mailed to buyers.D.C. Circuit, 2016; Top Class Actions (refunds) |
| 2015 | US | Brian Clement (Hippocrates Health Institute)West Palm Beach, Fla. | Raw-food and other programmes promoted to cancer patients, including two Ontario First Nations girls | Regulatory Florida Department of Health orders and a fine for unlicensed practice (Feb–Mar 2015). | Withdrawn Withdrawn for “insufficient evidence”. Nothing concluded against him.CTV News |
| 2016 | US | James Feijo (Daniel Chapter One)Portsmouth, R.I. | BioShark, CDC-7 and other cancer remedies | Criminal Federal plea: introducing an unapproved drug, plus a tax offence. | Convicted Six months in prison and six months’ home confinement (January 2016). See also the FTC civil case.EastBay RI |
| 2016 | US | Antonella Carpenter (Lase Med)Broken Arrow and Owasso, Okla. | Laser “hyperthermia”; tumours injected with food colouring or walnut-hull extract | Criminal Federal mail, wire and travel fraud (N.D. Okla.). | Convicted Convicted by a jury on 29 counts (February 2016); five years’ probation, the first year as home detention (October 2016).Justice Department; Public Radio Tulsa |
| 2017 | US | Dr. Stanislaw BurzynskiHouston, Tex. | Antineoplastons and cancer treatment at his clinic | Regulatory Texas Medical Board disciplinary case (2014–2017); FDA warning letters 2009–2013. | Disciplined Board order, March 2017: five years’ probation, $40,000 fine, $20,000 restitution to a former patient.AP / Washington Times, 3 Mar 2017 |
| 2017 | US | Robert O. Young (“pH Miracle”)Valley Center, Calif. | Intravenous baking soda for terminally ill cancer patients | Criminal San Diego County: practising medicine without a licence, theft. | Convicted Convicted on two counts (2016); pleaded to two more; three years eight months (2017). Convicted again in 2025 in a non-cancer case.NBC San Diego, 2017 |
| 2018 | Canada | Stanley Nowak (Genesis II Church / “Miracle Mineral Solution”)British Columbia | Sodium chlorite promoted for cancer, HIV/AIDS and autism | Regulatory offence Health Canada prosecution under the Food and Drugs Act, B.C. Provincial Court. | Convicted Pleaded guilty to 17 counts, November 2018: two-year conditional sentence with house arrest, probation, community service, sodium chlorite ban.Health Canada |
| 2018 | US | Isabel Kesari Gervais (“Dr. Rose Starr”)Hoover, Ala. | Fake naturopath who claimed to cure cancer | Criminal Federal wire fraud, aggravated identity theft, false statements. | Convicted Pleaded guilty; 75 months (May 2018).Alabama Reporter |
| 2018 | US | Kali v. Robert O. YoungSan Diego, Calif. | pH diet and baking-soda infusions instead of treatment for breast cancer | Civil Civil suit by a breast-cancer patient. | Judgment Jury awarded $105 million (October 2018), later reportedly reduced to about $25 million. Whether anything was collected is unknown.Insurance Journal |
| 2018 | US | CellMark Biopharma, Derek VestFlorida | CellAssure supplement sold to cancer patients | Civil FTC order. | Settled January 2018: randomized controlled trials required before any future cancer claim. No money.FTC |
| 2021 | US | Patrick BishopBirmingham, Ala. | PNC-27 peptide suppositories sold as a cancer treatment | Criminal Federal conspiracy to distribute adulterated and misbranded drugs. | Convicted Pleaded guilty; 30 months and $900,000 forfeiture (May 2021).U.S. Attorney, N.D. Ala. |
| 2021 | US | Dr. Benedict LiaoWest Covina, Calif. | “Allesgen”, an unapproved cancer drug sold as a supplement | Criminal Federal wire fraud, misbranding, unapproved new drug (C.D. Cal.). | Convicted Convicted on 26 felonies (November 2021). Sentence not found.U.S. Attorney, C.D. Cal. |
| 2023 | Canada | Pedro Acuna Saavedra (Primordial Beauty Inc.)Calgary, Alta. | “Miracle Mineral Solution” promoted for cancer, autism and COVID-19 | Regulatory offence Health Canada prosecution under the Food and Drugs Act. | Convicted Pleaded guilty: $12,000 fine and two years’ probation, July 2023.Health Canada, 19 Jul 2023 |
| 2023 | US | Mark, Jonathan, Jordan and Joseph Grenon (Genesis II Church)Bradenton, Fla. | “Miracle Mineral Solution” marketed for cancer, leukemia and later COVID-19 | Criminal Federal conspiracy to defraud the United States; criminal contempt. | Convicted Convicted July 2023: Jonathan and Jordan 151 months each, Mark and Joseph 60 months each.U.S. Attorney, S.D. Fla. |
Year is the year of the outcome, or of the charges where no outcome is known. Linked names have a full QuackeryWatch page.
Reading the record
In Canada, the null is the finding. Gaston Naessens was acquitted by a Quebec jury in 1989. When Ottawa Police and the CPSO searched the Canadian Cancer Research Group in 2007, no charges followed. The Competition Bureau’s 2008 Project False Hope produced one consent agreement and no fine. The criminal fraud charges against the Zoetron promoters, announced with some fanfare in 2005, simply disappear from the public record. Ravi Devgan did go to prison — but for defrauding the family of two disabled boys, not for his cancer practice, which cost him only his licence. The convictions that do exist came under the Food and Drugs Act, against two men selling sodium chlorite, with a conditional sentence in one case and a $12,000 fine in the other.
In the United States, prosecutors reach these sellers mostly by indirection. Jason Vale went to prison for defying an injunction. Geronimo Rubio’s Tijuana clinic was punished for its insurance bills. Toby McAdam’s black salve was dealt with as contempt of an FDA consent decree. Where fraud itself was charged, the results were mixed. Juries convicted Christine Daniel, Antonella Carpenter and Jimmy Keller; but a federal judge acquitted Stanislaw Burzynski of all 34 fraud counts in 1997, and he was never convicted of a crime. Hulda Clark’s unlicensed-practice charge was dismissed for delay.
The civil side catches more people but recovers less money. FTC orders routinely ban the claims and suspend the judgment. Real money was paid in some cases — Lane Labs, Kevin Trudeau, Roex, Daniel Chapter One — but the patients who paid most, those who gave up treatment that might have worked, are not compensated by a claims ban.
Outcomes we could not find
- Zoetron, Canada (2005). What happened to the Competition Act and fraud charges against Michael Reynolds and John Armstrong. A records request to the Competition Bureau, or the court files in Kitchener, Toronto or Penticton, would settle it.
- Feline Butcher (2008). The reported acquittal needs a court record or news report.
- Gaston Naessens (1989). The exact charges are reported inconsistently.
- Jason Vale’s second case (2019) and Dr. Benedict Liao’s sentence (2022).
If you have a court record, a news report or first-hand knowledge of any of these, QuackeryWatch would like to hear from you.
Related on QuackeryWatch
Take it further
QuackeryWatch is free, independent and reader-supported
No ads, no sponsors, no industry money. If this investigation was useful to you, here are two ways to keep the work going.
Dr. Polevoy recommends
Books on Health Fraud
Shop the reading list on Amazon →
One-time gift
Make a Donation
Secure payment by PayPal →
As an Amazon Associate, QuackeryWatch earns from qualifying purchases. It costs you nothing extra and never affects what we write.